Anish, thanks for launching discussion on this case!
There are a couple tips on how I look at vertical / AP dental changes. For the vertical (and you’ll see this on other posts discussion Buschang’s article), I use the traced CEJ as a guide. I find that helps me eyeball the difference.
For the AP dental changes on the molar, I eyeball the mesial contact point.
My goal in each of this is to narrow down the X or Y axis what is happening. Because of course teeth move in three dimensions and tip etc.
I’ve taken a screen shot below and marked a couple of lines. We also know 34 months – okay roughly 3 years of treatment.
3 yrs x 0.5mm/yr = 1.5mm AVERAGE mesial molar movement
A mandibular first molar is about 10.5mm wide mesiodistally so eyeing it that looks pretty close to me.
Does that make sense? [For me I have to keep it simple to break down the AP and Vertical because I totally agree that without breaking it down it appears it did not move much]